Recent data obtained by CBC News reveals that over 60% of individuals released with ankle monitors in Manitoba since August 2024 were rearrested or violated the terms of their release. The Justice Minister’s office reported that out of 530 individuals released under the program up to October 16, 2025, 243 were rearrested for various breaches or new offenses, 53 absconded by removing the device, 16 damaged the strap, and 12 let the battery die. Additionally, charges were stayed for 11 individuals, 19 were sentenced, and one was acquitted, while eight had their monitoring conditions removed, and one person died while wearing the device. As of the same date, 166 individuals were still being monitored with ankle bracelets.
Previously withheld, these statistics were disclosed by Justice Minister Matt Wiebe’s office following pressure from CBC News, who had obtained similar figures during a recent bail hearing. Prosecutors highlighted the program’s limitations based on the data, leading to the denial of bail for some accused individuals.
The ankle monitoring program, implemented in 2024 to enhance public safety and compliance with release conditions, utilizes GPS tracking and real-time communication features. However, despite the government’s assertion of success due to quick apprehension of offenders using GPS data, critics like criminal justice professor Michael Weinrath argue that the program has “failed miserably,” citing a high failure rate of 89% when including ongoing cases.
Defense lawyer Christopher Gamby offered a contrasting view, suggesting that detecting breaches via ankle monitors could be considered a success in some contexts. Nonetheless, concerns persist regarding the program’s effectiveness and allocation of resources, with Weinrath questioning the program’s efficacy given conflicting views within the justice system.
While Justice Minister Wiebe defends the program and its role in public safety, doubts linger about its cost-effectiveness and impact on crime prevention. The ongoing debate surrounding ankle monitoring underscores the need for continuous evaluation and potential reallocation of resources to address underlying issues contributing to criminal behavior.
Looking ahead, the province intends to assess and expand the ankle monitoring program based on community demand and feedback. The future trajectory of ankle monitoring in Manitoba remains under scrutiny as stakeholders evaluate its efficacy and impact on the justice system.