The creators of the independent film “As Deep as the Grave” unveiled a sneak peek of the digitally rendered version of Val Kilmer, who plays a key role in the movie, at CinemaCon in Las Vegas. The character, Father Fintan, portrayed by Kilmer, delivers a line in the trailer posthumously, as the actor passed away last year at the age of 65 due to pneumonia. The decision to use generative AI to bring Kilmer back for this historical drama sparked controversy when it was announced recently. The trailer showcases Kilmer’s character at different stages of his life.
Writer-director Coerte Voorhees, accompanied by his brother John, addressed the audience during a panel discussion, explaining the ethical considerations taken while using technology to bring a deceased actor back to the screen. They clarified that they collaborated with Kilmer’s family and the actors’ union, ensuring the process was handled respectfully. However, Coerte Voorhees refrained from labeling it as a Val Kilmer performance, stating that Kilmer’s influence was integral to the portrayal.
Producer John Voorhees acknowledged the risks involved in using AI-generated actors based on real individuals but highlighted their adherence to guidelines set by the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) union. This approach, focusing on consent, compensation, and collaboration, was established following a prolonged dispute between the union and studios, which led to the industry strike in 2023.
Apart from synthetic performers, another controversial category involves the recreation of real people, including employment-based digital replicas and digital alteration with performer consent. The use of computer technology to enhance actors’ performances predates the AI era, with instances like the digital de-aging technology employed in previous films.
The discussion around AI in the entertainment industry has intensified, with differing opinions on its impact. While some filmmakers, like Timur Bekmambetov, advocate for widespread AI integration, others, such as Rian Johnson, express concerns about its implications. The debate extends to the creation of AI-generated actors like Tilly Norwood, eliciting mixed reactions from industry professionals and audiences.
In the case of Val Kilmer’s digital replica in “As Deep as the Grave,” his estate granted permission for the replication, receiving compensation and providing archival material to aid the process. Notably, Kilmer had utilized AI technology during his lifetime to recreate his voice following health challenges, showcasing a prior familiarity with such tools.
The decision to include Kilmer’s digital likeness in the film was made after careful consideration and consultation with Kilmer’s family to ensure their endorsement. SAG-AFTRA’s stance on regulating AI use underscores the importance of fair compensation and maintaining the value of human performances in the film industry.
The movie featuring Val Kilmer’s digital appearance is set for release later this year, with the creators revealing that Kilmer’s character will be on screen for approximately one hour and 17 minutes. The total runtime of the film remains undisclosed but is expected to be significantly longer.