Cale Makar reflects on the changing landscape of college hockey since leaving UMass for the NHL with the Colorado Avalanche five years ago. Notable developments include the introduction of name, image, and likeness (NIL) compensation and the NCAA’s lifting of the ban on Canadian Hockey League (CHL) players. Makar observed a significant influx of players committing to Division I programs this offseason, culminating in Gavin McKenna, a top prospect for the 2026 NHL draft, choosing Penn State.
The shift has altered the decision-making process for players like Makar, who left Calgary to play for the UMass Minutemen and was named college hockey’s MVP in 2019. The changing rules have reshaped the relationship between the CHL and NCAA, prompting speculation on the future landscape of the sport.
The surge of CHL talent entering college hockey is expected to raise the competitive standard. Coaches anticipate CHL players to enhance team depth and potentially displace previous third- or fourth-line players. The influx of nearly 325 CHL players committing to U.S. colleges has also impacted the talent pool available to CHL teams.
The evolving scenario has sparked discussions on whether the NCAA will surpass the CHL as the primary NHL talent pipeline. Some, like Hockey East Conference Commissioner Steve Metcalf, believe that college hockey is gaining an edge in developing NHL prospects. The transition has already seen an increase in NHL draft picks coming from college, with notable examples like Macklin Celebrini and Owen Power.
While uncertainties remain, the flexibility for players to switch between CHL and college hockey offers the best of both worlds. This approach allows prospects to compete in various leagues before making decisions about their future development. NHL teams benefit from extended scouting opportunities, as exemplified by prospects like Cole Brown and Marcus Kearsey.
In conclusion, the evolving landscape of college hockey presents new opportunities and challenges for players, coaches, and stakeholders. The harmonious relationship between the CHL and NCAA may ultimately redefine the pathway to professional hockey for aspiring athletes.