On Thursday, Canadian filmmaker Ally Pankiw announced that she had declined a directing position for an upcoming Harry Potter television series, describing her decision as a stand against transphobia.
Pankiw shared a conversation on Instagram where she emphatically stated “Absolutely f–king not!” regarding her involvement in the new HBO Harry Potter series.
“It’s really this straightforward to decline funding transphobia!” Pankiw wrote in her post.
“(Additionally, this was for directing, not acting… obviously lol),” she clarified.
At 39, Pankiw has directed two episodes of the acclaimed sci-fi anthology series Black Mirror, the entire first season of the comedy series Feel Good, and the 2023 film I Used to be Funny, among other projects.
The message in question was dated April 21, but it does not indicate the identity of the person she was texting.

An Instagram post by director Ally Pankiw on Thursday, revealing her decision to decline a role in the new Harry Potter television series. (allypankiw/Instagram)
The anticipated series is scheduled for release on HBO Max on December 25, 2026, with the first season titled Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. This series draws inspiration from J.K. Rowling’s immensely popular Harry Potter fantasy book series, with the first season named after the original book. In Canada, the series will be available for streaming on Crave.
Rowling has faced backlash and scrutiny in recent years due to her opinions on transgender issues. In 2019, she tweeted in support of Maya Forstater, a researcher in the U.K. whose contract was terminated after she tweeted statements including: “I don’t believe that being a woman/female is a matter of identity or feelings. It is biology.” Rowling subsequently wrote an essay defending her stance on gender and sex.
In a post on X last month, Rowling reaffirmed her position, stating: “Trans women aren’t women, and if that offends you, be thankful you live in a society where you can freely express gender ideology, just as I can express the truth.”
Last year, she established the J.K. Rowling Women’s Fund, which utilizes her personal resources to provide legal assistance to individuals or organizations that have faced discrimination for believing that individuals cannot change from their assigned gender at birth.
-
Tim Hortons criticized for Harry Potter promotion seen as un-Canadian and anti-trans
-
J.K. Rowling responds to Vancouver Park Board’s apology regarding Harry Potter event
These perspectives have created divisions within the Harry Potter franchise, even among actors from the blockbuster film series. Recently, Canadian coffee chain Tim Hortons faced backlash for its collaboration with Harry Potter. Similar disputes have arisen regarding a 2025 park attraction in Vancouver, a video game released in 2023, and more.
Rowling’s public relations representatives informed CBC News that they have no comment on the matter.
Another director also declined the Harry Potter opportunity
Director and writer Kate Herron also revealed her own experience of turning down an opportunity to work on the series.
“Yes, thank you for that! Sending respect and love your way, Ally,” Herron commented on Pankiw’s post.
“They’ve reached out to me twice, and I’ve had to clarify that my answer will always be a no.”

Director Kate Herron attends the premiere of Margo’s Got Money Troubles during the South by Southwest Film Festival on March 12 in Austin, Texas. Herron has also declined to work on the Harry Potter television series. (Jack Plunkett/Invision/The Associated Press)
Herron directed the inaugural season of the Marvel Studios series Loki and has also helmed episodes of popular shows such as The Last of Us and Sex Education.
In an Instagram story shared on Thursday, Pankiw praised Herron’s decision.
“I also want to give a shoutout to the incredible [Kate Herron] who also said no… twice! That’s genuinely tough!” Pankiw remarked.
Representatives from Warner Bros. Discovery, the parent company of HBO, have yet to respond to CBC News regarding whether issues with refusals have arisen during the show’s production.
There has been no response from Pankiw’s representatives regarding further clarification on the text conversation.
