Lionel Carmant Leaves CAQ Cabinet, Prioritizes Family Amid Controversy

Lionel Carmant has announced his departure from his role as social services minister in the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) government, indicating he will serve as an Independent moving forward.

The veteran minister shared this challenging and “heart-wrenching” decision alongside Premier François Legault during a news conference on Thursday morning.

“The past few weeks have been tough and have compelled me to reassess my priorities,” he mentioned. “I am prioritizing my family.”

Sonia Bélanger, the current minister in charge of housing, will take over Carmant’s responsibilities as social services minister, while also overseeing seniors, as announced by Legault on Thursday afternoon.

Caroline Proulx, who previously managed the seniors’ portfolio, will now handle housing matters.

Carmant resigns following daughter’s open letter

Carmant’s resignation comes at a time when doctors across Quebec are gearing up for a legal challenge against the province’s special legislation — Bill 2 — which enforces a salary framework for physicians.

The federation representing Quebec’s medical specialists formally initiated its legal challenge on Wednesday, arguing that the government’s law is excessive and infringes upon several charter rights.

The federation is requesting the court to immediately halt the most burdensome aspects of the legislation until the case can be thoroughly examined.

Numerous physicians have already signaled their intention to exit Quebec’s public health-care system, with many actively applying for licenses to practice in other provinces following Health Minister Christian Dubé’s special law.

Among those contemplating departure from Quebec is Carmant’s daughter, a maternal-fetal medicine specialist. In a letter released in Le Devoir on Wednesday, Laurence Carmant expressed that she might relocate within Canada if the government does not “permit her to practice freely.”

“Regrettably, I will have no option but to leave for another province,” she stated.

WATCH | Lionel Carmant steps down, will sit as an Independent:

Quebec minister, Lionel Carmant, resigns as contention over doctor’s bill continues

October 30, 2025|

Duration

2:41

The longtime CAQ minister made the announcement alongside Premier François Legault. Lionel Carmant says the past few weeks have been difficult, but that he’s choosing his family.

She criticized the system as flawed and urged Dubé to reconsider the entire health-care framework instead of “placing blame on individuals.”

During his conversation with the media on Thursday, the former CAQ minister clarified that his decision “was not a resignation, but a choice between responsibilities.”

“I have always maintained that political engagement should be approached with balance, clarity, and honesty towards oneself and others,” he remarked.

Carmant did not address his daughter’s letter directly during the news conference.

Opposition highlights the significance of the message

Public Security Minister Ian Lafrenière praised Carmant as an exceptional minister, friend, and neighbor.

“It’s a challenging moment, to be honest, but I empathize with his situation,” Lafrenière commented on Thursday.

Marc Tanguay, the health critic for the Quebec Liberal Party, noted that the letter from Carmant’s daughter conveys a powerful message to Legault.

“She’s a highly specialized physician, she has the right to voice her opinion, and the fact that she chose to write a letter… speaks volumes,” he told reporters following Carmant’s announcement.

“As a father, I can sense the strain this has placed on family dynamics.”

Québec Solidaire MNA Manon Massé, who recently stated she is stepping away from politics, remarked that the government has lost an “excellent minister.”

“And that saddens me because we were able to engage in discussions with him. So I am uncertain about the direction the CAQ is taking,” she expressed.

Before entering politics, Carmant was a pediatric neurologist at CHU Sainte-Justine. He was elected as the representative for Taillon in 2018 and held the position of junior minister for health and social services from 2018 to 2022.

In his remarks on Thursday, he acknowledged the difficulty of leaving behind projects he is passionate about.

Legault expressed gratitude towards Carmant, stating he is “thankful” for his contributions.

WATCH | Towing the hard line on Bill 2 comes at a cost for Quebec premier:

François Legault takes political and personal hit with minister’s resignation over doctor’s bill

October 31, 2025|

Duration

3:38

Léger executive vice-president Sébastien Dallaire says by towing the hard line on Bill 2, the CAQ is trying to show it still has some bite.

Source

Latest articles